Thanks again, Matthew Lewis!
Would you mind sharing what you prefer about the old design and what you think it does better than the toggles?
We put a lot of thought into the new design and wanted to reduce the number of decisions the donor has to make. In the old design recurring donations were a two step decision: first whether they wanted to give in recurring, and then the period in which they wanted to give. The new toggles turn this into a single decision: clicking "monthly" is implicit to choosing both to give regularly
the period. This aims to reduce donor choice friction and increase the chances of them choosing to give regularly.
Would love to hear your thoughts!